Thursday, February 21, 2013

No Time for "Pan"-ic


One verse. I’m covering one verse. In actuality only one-half of one verse. Another three and a half verses will come into play with the next post to the blog. First though it’s important to focus on the “where” in this part of the story. The “where” will have significance on the “who” and the “why” later.

After having spent time in Bethsaida (“house of the hunt”; the fertile delta at the upper Jordan River), Jesus and his disciples walk north for 25 miles on the road to Caesarea Philippi – ending up on the outskirts of the city.

And there you have it. For most people, they’ll keep on reading… past the surface mention of this city (and something jaw-dropping happening to its north). Not us!

The outskirts of the fertile city (at the foot of Mount Hermon in the Golan Heights), with its numerous springs and flowing streams, where Jesus and his followers arrived was known as Banias (as well as a multitude of other names).

Let’s go wayyyyy back in time… Ever heard of the deity “Baal”? Well, this was a major connector to the area, which was “apparently known as Baal Hermon and Baal Gad in the Old Testament period.” [i] The pre-Hellenic deity Baal was associated with the site, and was a title used for various gods (even human officials). Baal meant “master” or “lord.” [ii]

“The Baal cult provided the greatest and most enduring threat to the exclusive worship of Yahweh among the ancient Israelites. …Originating perhaps in the observation of the fertilizing effects of rains and streams upon the receptive and reproductive soil, Baal worship became identical with nature-worship.” [iii] A match not made in heaven – between Baal and this area. Now, let’s move forward a bit in time to…

The 3rd century BCE and Alexander the Great. “The conquests of Alexander the Great brought the Greeks to the East, [and to this area]. The Greeks were taken by the natural beauty of the site, touched particularly by the cave in which the springs welled.” [iv] “This abundant water supply made the area very fertile and attractive for religious worship.” [v] In this Hellensitic period, “the Ptolemaic kings, in the 3rd century BCE, built a cult center there.” [vi] They “sanctified the cave, dedicating it to Pan, god of the forest and shepherds. [They named the area] Panias, later becoming Banias in Arabic pronunciation.” [vii]

To share more about Pan from Greek religion and mythology, he is “the god of the wild, shepherds and flocks, nature, of mountain wilds, hunting and rustic music, and companion of the nymphs.” [viii] Also, “Pan is connected to fertility and the season of spring; a goat-footed god of victory in battle [creator of panic in the enemy],… and of sexual and spiritual possession.” [ix]

The temenos (sacred precinct), also known as the Sanctuary of Pan, “was constructed on an elevated, 80-meter long natural terrace along the cliff which towered over the north of the city.” [x] This Sanctuary included temples, courtyards, a grotto and niches for ritual worship.

“The Pan cave was special, due to the deep natural chasm in the floor, which led to ground water. Animal sacrifices were thrown into this chasm.” [xi] “If the victims disappeared in the water, this was a sign that the god had accepted the offering. If, however, signs of blood appeared in the nearby springs, the sacrifice had been rejected.” [xii]

“In 20 BCE, the Panion [the region of the Greek God Pan] including Banias was annexed to the Kingdom of Herod the Great. Herod erected a temple of ‘white marble’ in Banias in honor of his patron [Roman emperor Augustus Caesar].” [xiii]

On my journey to Israel almost 10 years ago, I toured this archeological site with Rabbi Brian Zimmerman and members of his synagogue – Congregation Beth Am (Tampa, Florida). An artist’s impression of the Sanctuary of Pan was posted on the grounds.


To assist in your viewing pleasure, the Temple of Augustus erected by Herod was to the far left in the picture. Behind the temple was the Grotto of the God Pan (the cave). To its immediate right was the Court of Pan and the Nymphs. To its right (center in the impression) was the Temple of Zeus. By its right side in a narrow area was the Court of Nemesis. At the far right was the Tomb Temple of the Sacred Goats (with entry below and the ability to walk above it). Finally, to the right (bottom of the picture) was the Temple of Pan and the Dancing Goats.

Eventually, Herod’s son, Philip the Tetrarch (called Herod Philip II by some writers; whose birth name was Philip ben Herod [born to Cleopatra of Jerusalem who was Herod the Great’s fifth wife]), inherited the northeastern part of the Kingdom of Herod the Great, which included Banias. “Augustus Caesar made his own division of Herod’s kingdom, giving one half to Herod Archelaus, while dividing the other half into two, going to Herod Antipas and Philip.” [xiv] Philip the Tetrarch, unlike his half-brothers, “did not use Herod as a dynastic name.” [xv]

Philip the Tetrarch married Salome (daughter of Herodias and Herod II – also called Herod Philip I). As you may remember, Salome played a huge role in the execution of John the Baptist (MARK 6:17-28).

With this inheritance, Philip the Tetrarch came into rule in 4 BCE (until his death in 34 CE) and “founded a city at Banias, which became the administrative capital of Philip’s large tetrarchy.” [xvi] At some point in the 1st century CE with the date unclear, Philip “changed the city’s name from Caesarea to Caesarea Philippi so that it would not be confused with the coastal city of Caesarea, the capital of the territory ruled by his brother Herod Antipas.” [xvii]

The Sanctuary of Pan “continued its pagan activity well into the age of Christianity in the Byzantine era (4th to 6th century CE), but in time, the temples near the cave were neglected or ruined. The date and circumstances of the sanctuary’s destruction are not known.” [xviii]

Two photos from my trip follow. One shows the Court of Pan and the Nymphs with the ritual niche hewn into the cliff above the courtyard; the other, I am standing by the calm Banias stream (that no longer rushes by). Behind me is where the Temple of Augustus stood with the Grotto of Pan (the cave).





Through the years, through the hands of conquering armies, the name of this area has changed numerous times; however, Banias it remains until today.

We now have the “where.” The “who” and the “why” are about to come into focus.

NEXT
The Jewish ideas of the Messiah; why Banias; why “hush, hush”



[i] Caesarea Philippi – www.bibleplaces.com
[ii] Carthage, a History – Serge Lancel, p. 194
[iii] Baal -- Wikipedia
[iv] “The Sanctuary of Pan” signage at Banias archeological site
[v] Caesarea Philippi – www.bibleplaces.com
[vi] Banias -- Wikipedia
[vii] “The Sanctuary of Pan” signage at Banias archeological site
[viii] “The Lycidas of Theocritus Idyll 7” – Edwin L. Brown
[ix] Pan (god) & Banias -- Wikipedia
[x] Banias -- Wikipedia
[xi] “The Sanctuary of Pan” signage at Banias archeological site
[xii] “The Grotto of the God Pan” signage at Banias archeological site
[xiii] Banias -- Wikipedia
[xiv] Antiquities – Flavius Josephus
[xv] Cambridge Ancient History, Vol. 10, The Augustan Empire, 43 BC-AD 69 – Bowman, Champlin, Lintott
[xvi] Banias -- Wikipedia
[xvii] Living Application Bible, p. 1750
[xviii] “The Sanctuary of Pan” signage at Banias archeological site

Thursday, February 14, 2013

Blind Faith



Going on blind faith. That's what comes to mind when I consider this next section of verses.  But first for a geography / historical tidbit,…

Bethsaida -- "the house of the hunt." Located at the delta of the upper Jordan river entering to the Sea of Galilee (northern part), this area was known as a crossing of the ancient trade routes, for its year-round flow of water, with plenty of fish and game, as well as the fertile soil. [i]

DID YOU KNOW…?
Bethsaida was the birthplace of three of the disciples -- Andrew, Peter and Philip.

No sooner than Jesus and his disciples arrive, concerned citizens bring forward a blind man for healing. Similar to the healing of the deaf / mute man (MARK:7:31-37), Jesus takes the afflicted man outside the village. NOTE -- The healing of the deaf / mute man, and of this blind man in Bethsaida, are recorded only in MARK.

Last weekend, a conversation at a workshop that I attended at the Claremont School of Theology reminded me of this action taken by Jesus -- taking the blind man aside from others. Often we do the same when we are aware someone is in need. There's no need to make a big show of it; we don't want to embarrass the person in public. We focus on them, away from others. They have our undivided attention. We pour our love on them, give assistance, provide a listening ear,... The person receiving the attention is all the more appreciative of not being made a spectacle. Plus, it's a more honest exchange between people, don't you think?

And spit is involved again (from the previous story and now this one). When you think about it, while we might wince at the act of Jesus spitting on the man's eyes,… what is our first instinct when we cut ourselves or burn a finger? We put our injured finger into our mouth. Why? To ease the pain. To provide comfort (in a way). Also, in my study research, various sources indicated the healing power of spittle was important to those in the ancient world. Hence, what Jesus does is not out of the ordinary for the times.

But… Jesus doesn't heal the man on the first try. Yes? No? Maybe? Actually healing did occur. The man is no longer blind because he says, "I see people." They just look like trees walking around. Like a good optometrist, Jesus listens to his patient, then makes an adjustment. The man's sight is a perfect 20/20.

So what's the point of this story? Is it just to add another healing to the "Yay, Jesus Does It Again" statistical chart?

No. What this moment does is bring into focus what happened in verses 14-21. The disciples, who have been following Jesus for a long time, are themselves blind (or less harshly stated, they have blurred vision). They can't see clearly. This healing of the blind man "in progressive stages symbolizes the progressive journey to understanding that the disciples must make." [ii]

"Do you have eyes but fail to see, and ears but fail to hear?" [iii] Jesus gives vision to the blind and hearing to the deaf. In both stories, faith is the key. Take it on faith what Jesus is doing. Blind faith, if you will.

Yet it's difficult to put our trust into what is so often invisible. Right? It's sometimes hard to accept that we can't see God's truth all at once. In our "I want it now" society, patience is definitely a virtue in this instance, because God's truth is revealed over time. It's not a "one and done." What looks to be the definitive answer is only partial because there are many layers involved. And "time" could be days, weeks, months, years,… a lifetime.

As with the disciples, the learning doesn’t stop. The journey on the road continues. We set forth with blind faith so that we may be fully restored.

NEXT
"Our god is better than your God"


[i] Biblewalks.com -- Bethsaida
[ii] Harper Collins Bible Commentary, p. 911
[iii] MARK 8:18 (NIV)



Thursday, February 7, 2013

A Different Kind of Bread



Can relate to this? Heading out-of-town on a trip. Need to pack and short on time. Grab the necessary items but inevitably forget something -- only to realize it once on the plane or well on the road towards the destination. Happen to you? Happens to me on almost every trip that there's one thing I've left behind. Make a list, or not,… it still occurs.

So it is with the disciples in the beginning of this section of verses as they are in the boat crossing the Sea of Galilee. "I'm hungry. Where's the bread?" "Uh,… (searching frantically) …we forgot the bread." "What's with the 'we'? That was your responsibility. How could you forget the bread?!?" "I don't know." (Whining and grumbling in the cramped boat.) "How long before we reach the other side?" "It's going to be several hours." "Several hours?!? Great! That's just great!" Almost seems like a long road trip with the children arguing back and forth.

Jesus' reply comes seemingly out of left field. "Watch out for the yeast of the Pharisees and of Herod."

Say what?!? Now some head-scratching follows by the disciples regarding Jesus' warning. "He said that because we have no bread."

And the lesson on "bread" (and so much more) begins to unfold. But first…

Verse 14 is brilliantly written. "Now the disciples had forgotten to bring any bread; and they had only one loaf with them in the boat." [i]

Wait a second. They had forgotten to bring any bread, but they had a loaf in the boat; yet, the disciples state again later that they have no bread. But they have a loaf in the boat! That's what it says, right? Doesn't that constitute as bread?

This bread is different. The "Wonder-full" bread in the boat is Jesus.

But the disciples don't get it. No matter what happened previously (feeding 5,000+, feeding 4,000+ with a few available loaves to start with and ending up with much more). They don't understand the magnitude of what Jesus has done and is doing. That they are being fed. That their needs will be sufficiently handled. More on the disciples to come…

There are some significant tie-in's here -- as recent as verses 11 and 12 of this chapter. The Pharisees seek a sign but even with all that Jesus has done, they have zero faith in him. In verse 15, Jesus gives a warning about the yeast of the Pharisees as well.

For those who bake, it only takes a small amount of yeast to make a batch of bread rise, but as Leah * pointed out, "A pinch of yeast contaminates everything in the mixture." The false teaching of the Pharisees (MATTHEW 16:12) and their hypocritical behavior (LUKE 12:1) is the yeast that Jesus speaks about. A little bit goes a long way to contaminate all that is good. The same goes for Herod with his immoral, corrupt conduct.

DID YOU KNOW…?
While MARK mentions the yeast of the Pharisees and Herod, MATTHEW substitutes Sadducees for Herod. Why? "Mark's audience, mostly non-Jews, would've known about Herod, but not necessarily about the Jewish religious sect of the Sadducees. …This reference to Herod may mean the Herodians, a group of Jews who supported the king. Many Herodians were also Sadducees." [ii]

The Pharisees and Herod lack faith. Consider the disciples in this instance. They, too, lack faith. They can't see past Jesus' actions to understand his true power -- his inherent power ("dunamis").

Pedro * made several good points in discussion. "Yeast -- tiny living organisms -- you can't see them by the naked eye. You need a microscope to see them." Which ties into verses 17 and 18 about eyes that see and ears that hear. "If I can't see it, I won't believe it."

Then Pedro * followed this up with, "The disciples are focused on a material plan -- the need to survive: food, water, shelter. Jesus is focused on a spiritual plan, which they don't yet understand." Marc * mentioned, "Their theological view is being turned upside down." To which he emphatically added, "And we still don't get it!"

I'll conclude this blog post with a poignant statement made by Leah *. "Jesus is the new bread -- without contamination." How beautifully put!

NEXT
Next stop, Bethsaida; blind faith


[i] Mark 8:14 (NRSV)
[ii] Living Application Bible (NIV), p. 1749

* Member of the study group